Ticket 10569

We are using cons_tres to manage GPU allocation. We also would like to use gres to specify per-node features (specifically available scratch and video memory). These are defined in gres.conf:

  NodeName=merlin-g-001 Name=gpu Type=GTX1080 File=/dev/nvidia[0,1] Cores=0-15
  NodeName=merlin-g-001 Name=scratch Count=512

And slurm.conf:


  GresTypes=gpu,scratch
  AccountingStorageTRES=gres/scratch,gres/gpu,gres/gpu:GTX1080,gres/gpu:GTX1080Ti,ic/ofed
  NodeName=merlin-g-001 Weight=1 CPUs=16 RealMemory=128000 MemSpecLimit=25600 Sockets=1 CoresPerSocket=8 ThreadsPerCore=2 Gres=gpu:GTX1080:2,scratch:512 State=UNKNOWN


However, slurm is unable to allocate resources when specifying both --gpus and --gres. Example:

  $ sbatch --partition=gpu --gres=scratch:500 --gpus=1 --wrap 'sleep 10'
  sbatch: error: Batch job submission failed: Requested node configuration is not available

Oddly, it does find a configuration if the gres is less than or equal to the number of GPUs:

  $ sbatch --partition=gpu --gres=scratch:2,gpu:2 --gpus=2 --wrap 'sleep 10'
  Submitted batch job 9551

It also works if we specify the number of gpus using --gres instead of --gpus (resulting in a per-node constraint as opposed to a per-job constraint):

  $ sbatch --partition=gpu --gres=scratch:500,gpu:1 --wrap 'sleep 10'
  Submitted batch job 9552

Is this a known issue with how --gpus interacts with --gres, or is there an error in our configuration?

Part of the motivation for this related to implementing #9346 using gres instead of features. Since features are binary, specifying the video memory would require creating a feature for each class of graphics card (8G_GPU, 11G_GPU, etc). It would be much cleaner to specify this as an integer (--gres=gpumem:11G).